|

|
Films that Promote Peace
& Nonviolence
|

|
Gandhi
Gandhi
Richard
Attenborough, Ben
Kingsley, Candice
Bergen, Edward
Fox
In his epic masterpiece Gandhi, director Richard
Attenborough explores the inspiring, complicated life of Mohandas K. Gandhi,
the Indian lawyer who through ideological conviction and an impassioned sense of
political justice went on to become the spiritual leader of a nation and the
symbol of its hard-won independence. Ben
Kingsley won an Oscar in the title role, and he is supported by an all-star
cast that includes Candice
Bergen as photographer Margaret Bourke-White and John
Gielgud as Lord Irwin. This is a big story to tell, and Attenborough tackles
his subject head on, zeroing in on those critical events in Gandhi's life that
propelled him along his historic journey: his awakening to the injustice of
Britain's resistance to Indian independence; his renunciation of his personal
effects; his development of a "passive resistance" strategy in
retaliation against the British army (which later inspired Dr. Martin Luther
King); and, most memorably, his dramatic fasting in the name of his cause. As
Gandhi, Kingsley, turns in an unforgettable performance, cloaking himself in the
indomitable spirit of the soft-spoken yet determined pacifist, as he seamlessly
evolves from citizen to statesman to modern-day messiah. Bruce Kluger
TV Guide Review: Despite an intelligent title performance by Ben Kingsley
and impressive cinematography in the manner of David Lean, this huge, clunky
biopic offers less than meets the eye. Director Attenborough seeks not to
understand but to canonize his subject; as a result, both Gandhi's teachings and
the complexities of Indian political history are distorted and trivialized. The
film spans decades, opening in South Africa where Mohandas Gandhi (Kingsley) is
a struggling attorney victimized by that country's racial policies. Returning to
India, he develops a strategy of non-violent civil disobedience that proves more
effective than armed struggle in throwing off British imperial rule. The film is
at its best in its several melodramatic, large-scale "epic" sequences
(Salt March, post-Partition riots, assassination), but Gandhi remains a saintly
cipher; other major figures are even more carelessly drawn; e.g., Nehru, who
appears as a colorless Gandhi disciple (he was anything but), and Pakistan
founder Jinnah, who comes off as a Muslim Darth Vader. African playwright Athol
Fugard (Master Harold and the Boys) appears as General Smuts; Candice
Bergen is fun in a cameo as American photographer Margaret Bourke-White.
- 1982 Academy Award:
- Best Picture
- Best Actor - Ben Kingsley
- Best Director - Richard Attenborough
- Best Art Direction-Set Decoration - Stuart Craig, Bob Laing, Michael
Seirton
- Best Cinematography - Billy Williams, Ronnie Taylor
- Best Costume Design - John Mollo, Bhanu Athaiya
- Best Film Editing - John Bloom
- Best Original Screenplay - John Briley
Gandhi: An Autobiography:
The Story of My Experiments with Truth
Mahatma
Gandi Gandhi
Mahadev
Desai (Translator) Foreword by Sissela
Bok
Mohandas K. Gandhi is One of the most inspiring figures of our time. In his
classic autobiography he recounts the story of his life and how he developed his
concept of satyagraha, or active nonviolent resistance, which propelled the
Indian struggle for independence and countless other nonviolent struggles of the
twentieth century.
In a new foreword, peace expert and teacher Sissela Bok urges us to adopt
Gandhi's "attitude of experimenting. Of testing what will and will not bear
close scrutiny, what can and cannot be adapted to new circumstances," in
order to bring about change in our own lives and communities.
Learning Guide to:
Gandhi
Subjects: World/India & South Africa; U.S./Civil Rights;
Biography/Gandhi;
Character Development: Rebellion; Peacemakers;
Ethical Emphasis: Trustworthiness, Respect, Responsibility;
Fairness; Caring; Citizenship.
SELECTING THE MOVIE Quick
Discussion Topic
Age: 8+; Rated PG; Biography; 1982; 188 minutes; Color; Available from Social
Studies School Service.
Description: This movie is a biography of Mahatma Gandhi, the saint and
Indian social reformer.
Benefits: Gandhi would neither countenance the subjugation of his people
nor demean himself by hurting another human being. To reconcile these moral
imperatives, he used nonviolent civil disobedience to force governments to
change their policies and to achieve independence for India. Nonviolent civil
disobedience has been adopted by movements seeking social change or revolution
in many parts of the world, first by the Civil Rights Movement in the United
States and then by revolutions in the Philippines, Russia and other places.
Gandhi also campaigned for Hindu/Muslim brotherhood, against oppression of the
untouchables, and for reform in the treatment of women. He is personally
responsible for saving hundreds of thousands of lives in India through fasting
which stopped communal rioting. His leadership and example inspired people and
many governments, in India and throughout the world, to a new and higher level
of morality.
[Quick Discussion Topic:] Under the leadership
of Dr. Martin Luther King, the U.S. Civil Rights Movement adopted a strategy of
nonviolent civil disobedience based on Gandhi's teachings and the practices of
the Indian movement for independence. Since that time nonviolent civil
disobedience has been used by democratic revolutions in the Philippines, Russia
and more recently in Serbia and the Ivory Coast. In this way, Gandhi had a
profound effect, not only on India, but also on the United States and the rest
of the world. Children in the United States are taught in school about the great
achievements of Dr. King and the importance of nonviolent civil disobedience in
the struggle for civil rights in the U.S. To spark interest in this film, simply
tell young viewers that, "This is where Martin Luther King got a lot of his
ideas." The movie and this one comment will place the U.S. Civil Rights
Movement in a global context and make the film relevant to students in the U.S.
This is an emotion picture that speaks to the intelligent heart of the
viewer. It is likely to add significant memories to the fund of experience which
is used by each of us to understand our universe and to determine our future
actions.
Possible Problems: MODERATE. There are isolated scenes of men and women
being hit, clubbed and shot by policemen, soldiers and rioters. The scenes are
mildly graphic and disturbing but they are contrasted with the nonviolence of
the Mahatmah's followers and their willingness to put their bodies in jeopardy
rather than hurt someone else.
Selected Awards: 1982 Academy Awards: Best Picture, Best Director
(Attenborough), Best Actor (Kingsley), Best Art Direction/Set Decoration, Best
Cinematography, Best Costume Design, Best Film Editing, Best Original
Screenplay; 1982 British Academy Awards: Best Film, Best Director (Attenborough),
Best Actor (Kingsley), Best Supporting Actress (Hattangady); 1983 Golden
Globe Awards: Best Director (Attenborough), Best Actor-Drama (Kingsley),
Best Foreign Film, Best Screenplay; 1982 National Board of Review: Best
Actor (Kingsley).
Featured Actors: Ben Kingsley, Candice Bergen, Edward Fox, John Gielgud,
Trevor Howard, John Mills, Martin Sheen.
Director: Richard Attenborough.
USING THE MOVIE
Helpful Background:
- Gandhi was assassinated in 1948 by a conspiracy of fundamentalist Hindus
who were disturbed by his efforts to reform Indian society and to promote
Hindu-Moslem brotherhood.
- India and South Africa were British colonies. In the early 20th century
the British Empire stretched across the globe. Until recently South Africa
was one of the most segregated societies in the world. Indians had been
brought to South Africa by the British as laborers and merchants. They were
set apart as "coloreds" and given more privileges than blacks but
fewer privileges than whites. For example, they could not ride in first
class compartments in trains and could not walk on certain sidewalks. Gandhi
was educated in London and became a lawyer there. When he went to South
Africa and saw how his people were oppressed, he helped to organize a number
of successful protests. It was in South Africa that he first developed the
tactics of nonviolent civil disobedience. Later he returned to India and
lead a revolution against British colonial rule. India finally achieved
independence from Britain in 1947.
- Indian society was strictly segregated into castes for hundreds of years.
The lowest caste, the untouchables, were relegated to menial jobs such as
cleaning latrines and tanning hides. Upon coming into contact with an
untouchable, higher caste Indians would wash and perform religious rights to
cleanse themselves. If untouchables tried to improve themselves they were
subject to brutal repression. Gandhi tried to convince Indians to abandon
their discrimination against the untouchables. Although his family was from
a higher caste, he personally associated with untouchables and made it a
point to perform tasks, such as cleaning chamber pots, that had been
previously performed only by untouchables. While it is not dealt with
extensively in the movie, Gandhi also sought to lift many of the traditional
restrictions on women, although he maintained rigid control over his own
wife.
- For centuries, spinning cloth had been a cottage industry in India.
Families spun cloth for their own garments at home and some made money
selling their surplus. This ended with the invention of the power loom and
with British Rule. The machine manufacture of cloth was concentrated in
Great Britain and was a mechanism by which Britain drained wealth from
India. Gandhi sought, unsuccessfully, to reinstate spinning as an economic
activity in order to help purge India of British influence and control.
- India has many religious groups. The largest are the Hindus and the
Muslims. While there were tensions and some hostility between religious
groups before colonial rule, the British fanned the flames of religious
intolerance and hatred to keep the Indians from uniting against them. The
policy was called "Divide and Rule." Gandhi campaigned for
religious tolerance. On several occasions he fasted almost to death, to stop
sectarian rioting.
- The basic historical events in this movie are accurately reported.
However, it has been criticized as a "work of worship" for
reducing everything to black and white, for belittling other important
leaders in India's independence movement, and for portraying "virtually
all the Britains" Gandhi encountered as "buffoons or bigots."
See: Past Imperfect, Carnes, ed. pp 254 et seq. Some perspective on
Gandhi is added by this passage from Past Imperfect:
Indian audiences loved "Gandhi," and little wonder, since in it
all of India's faults are blamed on her British rulers. Hostility between
Hindus and Muslims for example - which still accounts for the loss of
hundreds of lives a year nearly half a century after the British
withdrawal - is blamed exclusively on the colonial policy of Divide and
Rule. The genuine fears of the Muslim minority are never presented, and
the brilliant lawyer who became the leader of the Muslim League, Mohammed
Ali Jinnah, is portrayed as nothing more than a languid and malevolent fop
- which makes the subsequent success of his campaign for Pakistan
inexplicable. Nor is there any mention of the Congress Party's colossal
wartime blunders - its precipitous withdrawal from the interim provincial
governments that might have led to independence for a united India, and
its demand that Britain "Quit India" just as the Japanese were
closing in on her eastern frontier - both of which Gandhi enthusiastically
supported, and which put him and all the other important Congress leaders
in prison for the duration, leaving the field wide open for Jinnah and his
followers to whip up Muslim support for carving up the country....
Gandhi fought two lifelong struggles: one for freedom from the British and
the other, more intense, for his own liberation from worldly desires. The
second, private struggle - the one that occupied most of Gandhi's time,
meant most to him, and profoundly affected his politics - is simply left
out of the film. So are other hard facts about him: He was difficult and
demanding, a tyrannical and emotionally abusive father, obsessed with the
working of his own and other peoples bowels, subject to long bouts of
depression during which he refused to speak to even his closest
associates, who were themselves notoriously quarrelsome and mutually
envious.
Gandhi did aspire to be a saint, but no one knew better than he how short
of that goal he fell. As the film memorably reminds us, when his dream of
a nonviolent and united India began to die, he faced down bloody-minded
mobs with astonishing courage, purchasing the lives of thousands of
innocent Muslims and Hindus by risking his own, over and over again. Yet
there is no hint of the real cause of the special anguish he felt. With
the sort of self-referential thinking that denotes either sainthood or
egomania, Gandhi had convinced himself that he was personally to blame for
the chaos that accompanied independence, not because he had made political
blunders but because he had failed somehow to be fully faithful to his
vows of renunciation. And so, to demonstrate to God (and to himself) that
at nearly eighty he had finally, irrevocably risen above the realm of the
flesh, he took to sleeping naked alongside the young female disciples who
were his constant companions.
Nehru was right: Gandhi was too much of a great man to be deified.
Despite these imperfections, "Gandhi" is a powerful tool for
educating children about one of the most remarkable men of the 20th century;
a man whose strategy of forcing social and political change through
nonviolent civil disobedience saved India, the United States, and several
other nations from unimaginable hardship; a man whose teachings continue to
affect the lives of hundreds of millions for the better.
- The term "Mahatma" means a man whose essence of being is great.
Gandhi's effort and his proposal for a solution to the predicament of modern
man was simply to "turn the spotlight inward." One can hardly
imagine a man more fit for such a title.
Words and phrases: "nonviolent civil disobedience,"Colony,
"British Empire," caste, untouchable, Brahmin, Hindu, Muslim, Sikh,
homespun, passes.
Discussion Questions:
- [Standard
Questions Suitable for Any Film].
- What benefits have the people of the United States derived from the
influence of Mahatma Gandhi?
- Explain the mechanism by which nonviolent civil disobedience works to
force a government to do what the protesters want.
- Would nonviolent civil disobedience have worked against Hitler, Stalin or
Pol Pot? [In comparison, analyze how Gandhi's campaign of civil disobedience
was able to gain independence for India. It mobilized public opinion
throughout the world and in Britain itself to force the rulers of that
country to reevaluate their actions and abandon Britain's evil policies with
respect to India. Would this have worked with Stalin, Hitler or Pol Pot?]
- Explain the mechanism of nonviolent civil disobedience. Include in your
answer responses to the following questions: How does civil disobedience
work on the mind of the oppressor? In which political structures is civil
disobedience most likely to work? In which political structures is civil
disobedience least likely to work?
- Was Gandhi correct when he said at the start of the march to the sea that
the British were not in control, but the protestors were? Explain your
answer?
- Compare and contrast Dr. Martin Luther King and Mahatma Gandhi describing
the situations they faced, their response to those situations, how their
response to the situations changed over time, and the political/religious
theory they applied.
- Compare and contrast Kundun and Mahatma Gandhi describing the situations
they faced, their response to those situation, how their response to the
situations changed over time, and the political/religious theory they
applied. See Learning Guide to Kundun.
- Compare the teachings of Gandhi with those of Jesus.
- What portions of Gandhi's character would you like others to emulate and
what, if any, do you find fault with?
- Would you consider Gandhi a role model?
- Would you consider him a saint? [Alternate question: Is there any other
person you know of who lived in the 20th century who was more saintly than
Gandhi?]
- Who were the untouchables? What did Gandhi want to do for them?
Character Development
Peacemakers/Rebellion
See questions 2 - 7 above and 16 below.
Ethical Emphasis
Teachwithmovies.org is associated with Character
Counts and uses The
Six Pillars of Character to organize ethical principals.
Mahatma Gandhi was the most important moral leader of the 20th century. His
method for challenging unjust laws and conducting a revolution, nonviolent
civil disobedience, is ethically pure and effective. It complies with each
of the The Six Pillars
of Character. Gandhi, in his public life tried to exemplify each of the
Six Pillars of Character. Most of the time he succeeded.
- Describe how Gandhi, in his public life, exemplified each of the The
Six Pillars of Character.
- Describe how nonviolent civil disobedience exemplifies each of the The
Six Pillars of Character.
- Compare and contrast Michael Collins and Mahatma Gandhi describing the
situations they faced, their response to the situations, how their response
to the situations changed over time, and the political/religious theory they
applied. See Learning
Guide to Michael Collins.
Bridges to Reading: Books recommended for middle school and junior high
readers include: Mohandas Gandhi: Power of the Spirit by Victoria Sherrow.
Other Movies on Related Topics: Kundun
and Michael
Collins.
Links to the Internet: For a web page about Gandhi, see Mahatma
Gandhi. See also Screenplay
for "Gandhi".
Bibliography: The Religions of Man, by Huston Smith and Past
Imperfect, Mark C. Carnes, Ed., Henry Holt and Company, New York, 1995.
GANDHI
is available from Social
Studies School Service.